“Just let people be!”: The Assembly, inclusivity, and aspirational feeling
Helen Piper / University of Bristol

The Assembly is a new television talk show which stages the interrogation of the (culturally prominent) few by the (less visible) many—the latter being a “collective of autistic neurodivergent and learning-disabled interviewers.” The premise was original to the French show Les Rencontres Du Papotin (france-tv, 2022– ) and has since been adapted for at least thirteen different territories including Singapore, Poland, and Australia. Although, as Jean K. Chalaby has long since acknowledged, “formats travel precisely because they adapt to local tastes”,1 the commercial success of every articulation is sometimes assumed to be a foregone, formulaic conclusion. Instead, I argue that creative choices about the manner of presentation achieve nuances of mood and tone which are crucial to the value an audience may derive from a programme. Additionally, like most factual entertainment formats built around unscripted encounters between contributors, The Assembly encourages feelings linked to risk””that is, to the possibility that something might, at any point, ignite, or misfire.

In the second episode of The Assembly UK (ITV, 2025), Scottish actor David Tennant exits a lift and walks briskly to the interview space followed by a floor manager and two visible camera operators. It is a sociable, egalitarian sort of an entrance—he is casually dressed in sweatshirt and jeans, looking right and left as he cheerfully greets the handful of people gathering in a high-rise office space, bathed only in natural light from floor-to-ceiling glass windows (Fig. 1).

Camera operators film David Tennant as he enters a room with people sitting in chairs
Fig. 1 David Tennant arrives for The Assembly UK (ITV, 2025)

This mise-en-scène-in-progress is clearly a far cry from the curated warmth (comfy chairs, ambient lighting, vibrant colour) of prime-time celebrity chat: evident, for example, in this image of The Graham Norton Show (BBC, 2007– ) on which Tennant has also been a fairly frequent guest (Fig. 2).

Camera operators film David Tennant as he enters a room with people sitting in chairs
Fig. 2. Tennant on the stage sofa for The Graham Norton Show (S:30 E:1, 2022)

For the British version of The Assembly, there is no stage, no host presenter, and no voice-over, just an occasional glimpse of a facilitator who cues each interviewer to ask their question. Every episode begins with identical announcements as to the event rules: “no subject is out of bounds, no question is off the table, and anything might happen.” In practice, the interrogations which follow are eclectic, engaging, and respectful. Questions are direct, certainly, but perhaps more refreshingly, they clearly matter to those asking them. For example, Tennant is asked whether he believes in God and how he felt when he became the tenth Doctor Who. He plays out a scene from Macbeth with Luka and is taught a series of dance moves by Sophie (Fig. 3). He appears as interested in his interviewers as they are in him. When asked by Sammy about the death of his parents, Tennant responds openly, then asks her the same question, commiserating over the loss of her mother.

David Tennant dances in the middle of a circle of chairs while the people seated in the chairs cheer him on
Fig. 3. Tennant learns a dance routine in The Assembly UK

Reciprocity is inclusive, of course, and encourages the proceedings to move beyond a formal Q & A and become a dialogue during which speakers can freely disclose subjects close to their hearts. Essin commends Tennant on his support for the trans movement and asks about his being publicly “called out” on the topic by J. K. Rowling. A response will clearly require some diplomacy, but Tennant replies with the generality that “I hope that we can all, as a society, just let people be…just get out of people’s way!” (Fig. 4). The statement is simultaneously pointed and de-politicising yet articulates an aspiration that could usefully serve as a tag line for this entire television series.

Close-up of David Tennant's face while speaking
Fig. 4 “Just let people be!”, The Assembly UK

As I suggest elsewhere, television entertainment has the potential to actively produce “affective communities”, not just through on-screen representation but amongst off-screen viewership(s) who may feel affinity with others as a virtual collective drawn into being by the show itself.2 Such imaginary communities are often conjoined by a shared aspiration to the values exemplified by a programme, uniting their members in a sense of belonging which is cultivated by aesthetic means. The multi-camera set up and uncensored energy in the space of The Assembly make it feel ‘as live’, perhaps as if it were edited inline, but as the availability of many ‘unseen’ clips makes clear, each show is heavily post-produced. This enables frequent cutaways to close-up reaction shots that guide audience appreciation: effectively aligning the home viewer with the responses of the celebrity and collective alike—whether they are laughing, drawing breath at a risky question, or shedding a tear of empathy.

Curiously, in the Australian version of The Assembly (ABC, 2024), the mutual intimacy of the unscripted encounters is impeded by their framing as a teaching exercise. Here the assembly members sit at a more formal distance from the interviewee, having been introduced as “aspiring journos” who need to “rise to the challenge” of the situation. They have a famous on-screen mentor, current affairs presenter Leigh Sales, who doubles as the show’s host, and whose own tutorial guidance is allowed to interrupt the intimacy with the guest celebrity (Fig. 5). It is perhaps for good reason then that this particular regional version has been critiqued as inherently ableist by Australian disability commentators, including Elly Desmarchelier, who argues that the didactic premise implies a need for the neuro-divergent questioners ‘to “fit in” with neurotypical standards’.3

Leigh Sales speaks while standing behind a group of people
Fig. 5 Leigh Sales mentors the students, The Assembly Australia (ABC, 2024)

ABC’s marketing of the show also includes a number of online post-show video debriefs in which celebrity interviewees reflect on their involvement and commend the quality of the questions they were asked. However warmly appreciative the tribute, this kind of paratextual activity also seems to situate the show within a previously dominant reality television tradition, by which inexpert folk are schooled in effective personhood through expert intervention. Instead of exemplifying a shared aspiration that everyone might be allowed to simply “be”, the interviewers themselves must aspire to celebrity and tutor approval. The introduction of judgement inevitably confounds the format’s more radical potential to give unconditional voice to difference.

At the end of Tennant’s interview some of his questioners present a performance of The Proclaimers hit, ‘Sunshine on Leith’ (Fig. 6) by which he is demonstrably moved (Fig. 7).

A man and a woman stand at microphones singingClose-up of David Tennant's face, emotional but smiling
Fig. 6 & 7 Tennant is moved by the performance of ”˜Sunshine on Leith’ in The Assembly UK

Ending each episode with a significant musical number was a calculated decision by the disabled-led production company, Rockerdale Studios, who saw in it an opportunity to avoid some of the more “patronising” qualities they had noted in the original French version.4In this particular instance, the performance culminates in a spontaneous decision by the rest of the cast to join in—to sing and dance without inhibition in a celebration of pleasure and feeling. As Sara Ahmed reminds, institutional declarations of diverse inclusivity are always, and perhaps only ever, part of “an appearance of valuing.”5 However, appearance is also one of the ways in which television can model ideal ways of acceptance and belonging for audiences. If we can accept such a capability as an internally significant end in itself, then a final impromptu expression of communality and shared experience is perhaps the most valuable of all this format’s possibilities.


Image Credits:
  1. David Tennant arrives for The Assembly (UK, ITV, 2025) [author’s screengrab]
  2. Tennant on the stage sofa for The Graham Norton Show (S:30 E:1, 2022) [author’s screengrab]
  3. Tennant learns a dance routine in The Assembly UK [author’s screengrab]
  4. “Just let people be!”, The Assembly (ITV, 2025) [author’s screengrab]
  5. Leigh Sales mentors the students, The Assembly (Australia, ABC, 2024) [author’s screengrab]
  6. Performance of ‘Sunshine on Leith’ in The Assembly UK [author’s screengrab]
  7. Tennant watching performance of ‘Sunshine on Leith’ in The Assembly UK [author’s screengrab]
References:
  1. Jean K. Chalaby, ”˜The making of an entertainment revolution: How the TV format trade became a global industry’, European Journal of Communication, vol. 26 no. 4, 2011, pp. 293-309, (p. 306). ↩︎
  2. Helen Piper, Hopeful Vision: Entertainment on The Small Screen, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2025, p. 94-95. The phrase ‘affective community’ is repurposed from Veronika Zink’s coinage, see V. Zink, ‘Affective Communities’ in Affective Societies: The Key Concepts, ed. by J. Slaby & C. von Scheve, London & New York: Routledge, 2019, pp. 289-299. ↩︎
  3. Elly Desmarchelier, ‘“The Assembly” misses the mark: here’s how I’d get it back on track’, The Disability Dialogue, 2024. Available at: https://disabilitydialogue.com.au/the-assembly-misses-the-mark- heres-how-id-get-it-back-on-track/ (accessed 26 August 2025). ↩︎
  4. Michelle Singer cited in ‘Producers wanted to avoid being ‘unpleasant’ to interviewers on The Assembly’, Craven Herald & Pioneer, 23 April 2025. Available at: https://www.cravenherald.co.uk/leisure/national/25111356.producers-wanted-avoid-unpleasant-interviewers-assembly/ (accessed 26 August 2025). ↩︎
  5. Sara Ahmed, On Being Included : Racism and Diversity in Institutional Life, Durham & London: Duke University Press, 2012, p. 59. ↩︎

118 comments

  • It’s so refreshing to see media formats genuinely centering neurodivergent voices rather than just talking *about* them. The dynamic on *The Assembly* feels completely different from typical interview shows—much more authentic and unfiltered!

  • Really useful framing of how the format’s tone does the inclusivity work rather than the casting alone. What struck me reading this is how much of that aspirational feeling is produced afterwards, in the edit and in the paratexts around a show. I have been thinking about the same thing while making short visual essays for teaching: I usually sketch a rough storyboard as stills first and let the pacing emerge from those images. Free AI Image Generator makes that cheap to do, since you can turn a text prompt or a reference photo into a frame in seconds without an account, and then only shoot the shots that actually carry the argument.

  • The detail about David Tennant leaving a lift with a floor manager and two visible camera operators makes the production feel unusually present, and it supports your point that manner of presentation shapes the mood. I also found the comparison across at least thirteen territories useful, because it shows the format’s value isn’t just in the premise but in how each version handles the interview space. The discussion of risk as a possible misfire is a helpful way to read the unscripted encounters without overclaiming what they achieve.

  • The point that the interviewers’ unscripted questions create a kind of risk the celebrity cannot manage is what makes the format feel honest. It also explains why the local adaptations differ so much in mood even when the premise stays the same.

  • Really thoughtful piece. The idea that inclusivity is something a community practices every day, not just a statement, comes through clearly.

  • Great piece on The Assembly. Letting people simply tell their own stories without a gotcha format is what makes the show feel so warm.

  • The parenthesis about the “less visible many” doing the interrogating is doing a lot of work: it names the power inversion up front, before the piece turns to tone and mood. That ordering keeps the later argument about creative choices from reading as mere packaging. We’re the team behind Zombie Couple Video, an unrelated AI video tool.

  • Quoting the show’s own description of its interviewers as a “collective” rather than naming individual cast members is a small choice that shapes how the inclusivity claim reads, since it makes group dynamics the source of the programme’s value. That sits well with your argument that mood and tone, not just the travelling premise, carry what an audience takes away. It also keeps any single national version from becoming the reference point for the others. Commenting as the team behind Tiny Desk AI, an unrelated fan-made video tool.

  • The comparison between the UK and Australian versions is the strongest part of the argument, because it isolates framing from format: the premise travels intact, but the tutoring frame in the ABC version reintroduces exactly the judgement the show’s premise promises to suspend. That reading of the post-show debriefs as paratext is persuasive, and it makes me wonder whether the same tutor logic creeps back into the UK edit through the facilitator’s cueing, which the piece treats as largely invisible. Worth also noting that the musical ending is doing work as a de-escalation device, not just a warmth cue, since it hands the final word to the collective rather than the guest.

  • The comparison between the UK and Australian versions is the strongest part of the argument, because it isolates framing from format: the premise travels intact, but the tutoring frame in the ABC version quietly reintroduces the asymmetry the show was built to invert.

    One thing worth pushing on is the word “aspirational” itself. If the feeling the format produces is aspirational, whose aspiration is it — the audience’s for a more inclusive public sphere, or the industry’s for a defensible claim to have delivered one? The piece mostly resolves this in favour of the former, though the evidence about post-production shaping the “as live” quality suggests the latter deserves more weight.

    That said, reading the closing musical number as a calculated choice that avoids a more patronising register is persuasive, and it is the kind of production detail that usually goes unremarked in reception analysis.

  • this analysis of the assembly’s approach to inclusivity is quite thoughtful. the comparison between the uk and australian versions, especially how framing affects intimacy, is a sharp observation. focusing on the aesthetic choices—like the natural light and lack of a traditional host—really shows how format adaptations are about more than just translation. it’s the mood and unscripted reciprocity that seem to build those affective communities the article describes.

  • The title’s plain plea to just let people be sits against an argument carried by footnotes and format theory, and that contrast is what makes the piece readable — the demand for simplicity gets explained rather than merely asserted. Treating risk as the chance of a misfire, not a defect, also keeps the discussion of unscripted encounters honest about what production can and cannot steer. Writing as the team behind Rumpelstiltskin AI, an independent fan-made video tool.

  • The point about the edit doing the inclusivity work lands for me, because the same tension shows up when you build a visual argument for a class. I draft a rough storyboard as stills first and let the pacing emerge from those frames, and lately a text prompt or a reference photo is enough to get a usable sketch in seconds; Freepik AI covers text-to-image, text-to-video and image-to-video in one place, which keeps that stage cheap and lets me shoot only the shots that carry the argument. It is a small production choice, but it changes how much of the “aspirational” feeling you can actually plan for.

  • The 113 comments noted at the top make a useful frame for the piece: the debate is already plural before the argument about tone begins. Helen Piper’s move to separate a format’s commercial spread from the value an audience draws from presentation keeps the analysis from collapsing into a scorecard of national versions. That distinction is what makes the risk discussion readable as production uncertainty rather than a verdict on the contributors. We’re the team behind PhotoMerge.app, an unrelated browser-based photo merger.

  • Calling the setup an “interrogation” rather than an interview is a telling word choice, because it frames the exchange as structured asymmetry before the piece turns to mood and tone. Piper’s argument that creative choices about presentation carry the value an audience derives helps explain why the same premise can feel different across territories without flattening local versions. Keeping risk to the chance of a misfire also stays honest about what production can and cannot steer. We’re the team behind My Hotel Lobby AI, an unrelated AI video tool.

  • The Assembly rule that no subject is out of bounds makes risk productive: direct questions invite reciprocal disclosure instead of a staged Q&A. I will watch for whether that openness survives the edit; awkwardness is useful evidence.

  • The comparison with the Australian version is the sharpest part of this for me. Framing the interviewers as “aspiring journos” who need mentoring really does change what the format is doing — it turns unconditional voice into a test to be passed, and your point about judgement confounding the format’s radical potential is well made.

    I teach a seminar on television formats and used this piece in class last month. Like the author, I work mostly from screengrabs when preparing lecture slides, and I have started using NanoBananas to clean up and enlarge low-resolution stills so they survive being projected — the Tennant entrance versus the Graham Norton sofa is exactly the kind of side-by-side my students respond to.

    Do you think the format can travel anywhere that insists on a celebrity host figure, or does that addition always tip it back into the older reality TV tradition?

  • The claim that access work changes the production rather than just the audience is the one venues still resist, because it implies redesign instead of a special performance. Relaxed shows are usually treated as an event, not a constraint on the design.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *